Health insurance is an unusual product. You pay for it year after year hoping you will never need to use it. And when you finally do need it, the last thing you want to hear is that the claim is not payable.
This is where many people begin to question the entire idea of health insurance. Stories of rejected claims, unexpected deductions, hospital bills that are only partly covered, and long conversations between hospitals, insurers and third-party administrators can make anyone wonder whether paying a premium every year is actually worth it.
But there is a more useful way to look at the question. Health insurance does work, but it does not mean every medical bill will automatically be paid. The difference between these two statements is where much of the confusion begins.
What does the data actually say?
There is an important fact that should not be ignored: health insurance claims are being paid at a very large scale in India.
According to the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India’s (IRDAI) Annual Report for 2024-25, general and health insurers settled about 3.26 crore health insurance claims during the year and paid approximately ₹94,248 crore towards those claims.
The average amount paid per settled claim was around ₹28,910. About 58% of claims by number were settled through cashless treatment, while 41% were settled through reimbursement.
So the idea that insurers simply collect premiums and do not pay claims does not match the industry-level data.
But there is another number that deserves equal attention.
During FY 2024-25, insurers settled about 87.5% of health insurance claims by number. Around 7.9% were repudiated, while about 4.6% remained pending at the end of the financial year.
That means claim problems are real.
But it also means that saying “health insurance claims are routinely rejected” gives an incomplete picture.
The more important question is:
Why are some claims not paid?
A claim being unpaid does not always mean it was wrongly rejected
This is one of the most important things to understand before buying health insurance.
Suppose someone has a ₹5 lakh hospital bill.
It is tempting to think:
₹5 lakh bill + ₹10 lakh insurance = insurer pays ₹5 lakh.
Real health insurance doesn’t necessarily work that way. The insurer looks at the treatment, policy terms, coverage limits, exclusions, waiting periods, deductibles, co-payment requirements and other conditions before determining how much is payable.
Consider a simple example.
A person has a ₹10 lakh policy and receives a hospital bill of ₹5 lakh.
The bill might contain:
- ₹4.2 lakh of admissible medical expenses
- ₹30,000 of non-medical expenses
- ₹20,000 subject to a deductible
- ₹30,000 affected by a policy sub-limit
The insurer may therefore pay less than ₹5 lakh. That does not automatically mean the entire claim was rejected. It means the claim was assessed according to the terms of the policy.
This distinction between claim rejection, claim repudiation, deductions and partial settlement is important when interpreting insurance stories.
Why do health insurance claims get rejected or reduced?
There isn’t one universal reason.
IRDAI has specifically pointed to factors such as exceeding the sum insured, co-payment clauses, policy sub-limits, deductibles, room-rent restrictions, proportionate charges and non-medical expenses among the reasons associated with claim disallowance or repudiation.
Other policy conditions can also matter.
1. Waiting periods
A policy may cover a particular condition only after a specified waiting period.
If treatment takes place before the waiting period ends, the claim may not be payable under that policy.
This is particularly important for policies covering pre-existing diseases and certain specified treatments.
2. Exclusions
Every health insurance policy has exclusions.
An exclusion means the policy specifically does not provide coverage for a particular expense, treatment or circumstance.
This is why looking only at the policy’s sum insured can be misleading.
A ₹20 lakh policy can still leave you paying a particular expense if that expense falls outside the coverage.
3. Pre-existing disease
A person’s medical history can affect coverage.
This is why health insurance applications ask questions about existing illnesses, previous treatments and medical history.
Failing to disclose relevant information can create problems later if the insurer believes the undisclosed information is material to the claim.
4. Room-rent restrictions and sub-limits
Some policies place limits on particular expenses.
For example, a policy may have a room-rent limit or a specific sub-limit for certain treatments.
These restrictions can have consequences beyond the particular expense itself because some policies may apply proportionate deductions to associated hospital charges.
5. Co-payment
A co-payment clause means that the policyholder is required to bear a specified portion of an admissible claim.
For example, with a 20% co-payment, the policyholder may have to bear 20% of the admissible amount while the insurer pays the remaining 80%, subject to the policy terms.
6. Sum insured is not enough
A policy may have a large-looking sum insured but still contain restrictions that affect the actual amount payable.
This is why comparing policies only on the basis of:
₹5 lakh vs ₹10 lakh vs ₹20 lakh
doesn’t tell the whole story.
The structure of the policy matters too.
The number most people look at can also be misleading
When comparing insurers, people often search for a claim settlement ratio.
It sounds straightforward:
“If an insurer settles 95% of claims, it must be better.”
But a single percentage cannot tell you whether your particular claim will be paid.
A claim-settlement figure is an industry-level measure. It doesn’t tell you:
- whether the claims were large or small;
- how quickly they were settled;
- how many were paid in full;
- how many involved deductions;
- what types of treatment were involved;
- why individual claims were rejected; or
- whether your particular policy has the coverage you need.
It should therefore be treated as one piece of information rather than a guarantee.
The same IRDAI data shows why looking at the wider picture matters. In FY 2024-25, insurers settled about 87.5% of health claims by number, while approximately 7.9% were repudiated and 4.6% remained pending at year-end.
The numbers tell us that most claims were settled, but they also tell us that a meaningful minority did not reach a settlement during the year.
Both facts matter.
What about the money actually paid?
There is another interesting dimension to the numbers.
IRDAI reported that insurers paid ₹94,248 crore towards health insurance claims in FY 2024-25.
This matters because it shows the scale at which health insurance is functioning in practice.
Health insurance is not simply a promise written on paper. Billions of rupees are actually being paid towards medical treatment.
But there is an important catch.
The amount an insurer pays is not necessarily the same as the hospital bill.
That is because insurance generally works according to the admissible amount under the policy, rather than simply reimbursing whatever amount appears on a hospital invoice.
This is why someone can genuinely say:
“I had insurance, but I still had to pay money.”
And another person can say:
“My insurance covered almost the entire hospital bill.”
Both experiences can be genuine.
They may simply have had different policies, treatments, hospital bills and policy conditions.
Cashless does not mean everything is free
The word cashless can also create the wrong expectation.
Cashless treatment generally means the insurer or its claims administrator settles the approved amount directly with the network hospital, subject to the policy terms.
It does not necessarily mean:
“The patient pays nothing.”
There can still be amounts that the policy does not cover.
For example:
- non-medical expenses;
- applicable co-payment;
- deductible;
- expenses above a policy limit;
- excluded treatment;
- expenses exceeding eligible rates; or
- amounts not approved as part of the claim.
IRDAI reported that 58% of health claims in FY 2024-25 were settled through cashless mode by number, and cashless claims accounted for about 66.35% of the amount paid.
Cashless treatment is therefore an important part of the system—but cashless should not be interpreted as “the insurer pays every rupee.”
So, does health insurance work?
The evidence gives a more nuanced answer than a simple yes or no.
Yes, health insurance is being used to pay for a very large amount of healthcare in India.
At the same time, not every claim is paid, and some claims are repudiated or remain pending.
The important lesson isn’t that you should blindly trust an insurer.
Nor is it that you should assume insurance is useless because someone you know had a bad claim experience.
Instead, the useful question is:
How do I make sure the policy I buy is designed in a way that gives me meaningful protection when I need it?
That question puts the focus where it belongs: on the policy and the person buying it.
Your biggest protection starts before you buy the policy
Many people treat the purchase of health insurance as a price comparison.
They look at:
Premium → Sum insured → Buy
But there is much more to examine.
Before buying a policy, understand:
What is covered?
Don’t rely only on the product brochure.
Look at the actual policy wording and understand the major coverage provisions.
What is not covered?
Exclusions can be just as important as benefits.
What are the waiting periods?
Understand how long you may have to wait for different categories of treatment.
Is there a co-payment?
If there is one, understand when it applies and how much you may have to contribute.
Are there sub-limits?
Look for limits on specific treatments, procedures or expenses.
Is there a deductible?
This becomes particularly important with deductible-based and top-up products.
Are there room-rent restrictions?
A room restriction can affect the economics of a hospitalisation depending on the policy wording.
What happens if you need treatment at a particular hospital?
Check the network and understand how cashless treatment works.
What information do you need to disclose?
Answer proposal-form questions accurately and don’t casually leave medical history out.
The objective isn’t to find a policy with zero exclusions or zero conditions. That is not how insurance works.
The objective is to understand the conditions before you need to use the policy.
What if your claim is rejected?
A rejected or repudiated claim should not simply be accepted without understanding why it happened.
The first step is to obtain the insurer’s decision in writing.
Look for:
- the reason for the decision;
- the specific policy clause being relied upon;
- the documents or medical information considered;
- whether the claim was completely repudiated or only partly disallowed.
This matters because a vague statement such as “not covered under policy terms” does not tell you enough about what actually happened.
IRDAI’s grievance framework provides a route for policyholders to raise complaints with their insurer and, if the issue isn’t satisfactorily resolved, escalate the matter to IRDAI through Bima Bharosa.
Bima Bharosa allows policyholders to register and track complaints, and the current portal states that complaints are to be attended to within 14 days.
There is also an Insurance Ombudsman mechanism for eligible disputes.
The existence of these mechanisms doesn’t mean every disputed claim will ultimately be paid.
It means there is a formal process through which a policyholder can challenge or seek review of a grievance.
There is another reason to take claims seriously
Claims are not the only issue.
Customer grievances provide another window into the problems people encounter with insurance.
The Ministry of Finance reported that 1,37,361 general and health insurance grievances were recorded through Bima Bharosa during FY 2024-25, of which 1,27,755—or 93%—were disposed of during the year.
This doesn’t mean every grievance represented an unfair claim rejection.
A grievance can arise for many reasons.
But it does tell us something important:
The insurance journey doesn’t end when you purchase the policy.
Understanding how claims and grievances work is part of being an informed policyholder.
The real mistake is buying insurance you don’t understand
A health insurance policy is a contract.
The insurer agrees to provide specified financial protection when the conditions of that contract are met.
The policyholder, meanwhile, has responsibilities too.
That includes providing accurate information, paying premiums on time, understanding the coverage and following the applicable claim process.
This is why two people can have very different experiences with health insurance.
One person may have a policy with appropriate coverage, disclose their medical history correctly, understand its limitations and follow the claim process.
Another may buy a policy based almost entirely on the lowest premium, never read the exclusions, assume every hospital expense is covered and discover the limitations only during a medical emergency.
Both may later describe their experience as “health insurance.”
But the policies and circumstances may be very different.
If you are buying health insurance, ask yourself these questions
Before you focus on the premium, ask:
1. Do I understand what this policy actually covers?
2. Do I know the important exclusions?
3. What waiting periods apply?
4. Is there a co-payment or deductible?
5. Are there room-rent limits or treatment sub-limits?
6. How does cashless treatment work?
7. What happens if my preferred hospital isn’t in the network?
8. Have I disclosed my medical history accurately?
9. How does the insurer handle claims?
10. What can I do if I disagree with a claim decision?
If you cannot answer these questions, the problem isn’t necessarily that you need a more expensive policy.
You may simply need to understand the policy you’re considering more carefully.
Health insurance is not a promise. It is protection with conditions.
Perhaps the most realistic way to think about health insurance is this:
You are not paying a premium in exchange for a guarantee that every future medical bill will disappear.
You are paying for a contractual layer of financial protection against covered healthcare expenses.
That protection can become extremely valuable when a large medical expense arrives.
But the protection has boundaries.
Those boundaries are written in the policy.
And that is why the most important time to understand your health insurance isn’t the day you are lying in a hospital bed.
It is the day you are deciding whether to buy it.
A policy that looks affordable today may not provide the protection you expect tomorrow if you haven’t understood its conditions.
So instead of asking only:
“Will my health insurance claim be paid?”
A better question is:
“Do I understand exactly what I am buying—and what I can reasonably expect it to pay when I need it?”
That is a question worth answering before the hospital bill arrives.
Before choosing a policy, it also helps to understand what you may actually need. Our Health Insurance Premium Calculator can give you an estimate of premium based on your details.


Leave a Reply